Plated Substrate Surface Finishes for Advanced Microelectronics Packaging

Enforcing ENEPIG thickness windows per IPC-4556 eliminates galvanic hyper-corrosion, guaranteeing flip-chip solder joint integrity and wire bond reliability.

03.10.26 16 min

Bath

Substrate copper traces connect to integrated circuit dies, wire bonds, and board-level solder joints through electroless or electrolytic surface finishes. In high-density packaging, these protective coatings keep copper from oxidizing in storage and ensure clean intermetallic bonding during assembly. Stack selection ultimately determines microbump quality, wire bond pull strength, and thermal fatigue resistance in ball grid arrays and system-in-package modules.

Electroless Nickel Electroless Palladium Immersion Gold (ENEPIG) remains the standard finish for complex substrate layouts. The nickel deposit acts as a structural diffusion barrier to halt copper migration into solder joints. Over it, the intermediate palladium film stops nickel passivation, prevents galvanic hyper-corrosion during gold immersion, and accepts gold, aluminum, and copper wire bonds.

The immersion gold cap preserves solderability on the shelf without contributing enough gold to cause embrittling gold-tin intermetallics.

Machined brass motor housing and raw aluminum tubular frame components rest on a neutral testing workbench inside the production facility.

Electroless Nickel Electroless Palladium Immersion Gold Processing

Chemical reduction deposits each metallic layer onto the copper pads without external electrical current. For the nickel layer, sodium hypophosphite serves as the reducing agent, leaving a nickel-phosphorus alloy with seven to eleven weight percent phosphorus. Bath temperature, pH, and stabilizer levels dictate how much phosphorus co-deposits.

Tight control over this composition is vital: drops below seven percent sacrifice corrosion resistance, while phosphorus exceeding twelve weight percent breeds brittle phases during reflow.

Plating Finish Chemistries and Packaging Compatibility Guidelines
Surface Finish Layer Architecture Typical Thickness Window Wire Bond Compatibility Microbump Solderability
ENIG Electroless Ni / Immersion Au Ni: 3.0 ~ 6.0 µm, Au: 0.02 ~ 0.05 µm Al Wire Only Good (Risk of Black Pad)
ENEPIG Electroless Ni / Electroless Pd / Immersion Au Ni: 3.0 ~ 6.0 µm, Pd: 0.05 ~ 0.15 µm, Au: 0.02 ~ 0.05 µm Au, Al, Cu, Ag Wire Excellent
EPAG Electroless Pd / Autocatalytic Au Pd: 0.05 ~ 0.20 µm, Au: 0.02 ~ 0.08 µm Au, Cu Wire Excellent (Zero Ni Voiding)
DIG Direct Immersion Gold over Cu Au: 0.02 ~ 0.05 µm Limited Moderate (High Cu Dissolution)
Electrolytic Ni/Au Electroplated Ni / Hard or Soft Au Ni: 2.0 ~ 5.0 µm, Au: 0.30 ~ 0.80 µm Au Wire (Soft Au) Poor (Excess Au Embrittlement)

Autocatalytic palladium plating deposits directly over the activated nickel using formic acid or amine-borane reducing agents. Maintaining bath temperature within two degrees Celsius prevents spontaneous solution decomposition. At fifty to one hundred nanometers, the resulting palladium layer protects the nickel against oxidation while adding negligible electrical resistance.

Plating panels with an electroless palladium layer between fifty and one hundred nanometers completely blocks copper diffusion during five-hundred-hour thermal aging at one hundred fifty degrees Celsius.

Immersion gold deposits via a displacement mechanism: surface nickel or palladium atoms dissolve into the bath, releasing electrons that reduce gold ions onto the pad. Autocatalytic gold chemistries supplement displacement with chemical reducing agents, building gold layers past fifty nanometers without eating into underlying metals. Eliminating nickel altogether yields Electroless Palladium Autocatalytic Gold (EPAG), a stack suited for ultra-fine microbump pitches below thirty microns.

A digital render shows a white articulated robotic arm placing a packaged luxury product into an open carton on an industrial table.

Plating Physics in Sub-Thirty Micron Substrate Features

Inside narrow microvias, fluid dynamics govern local ion replenishment during chemical plating. When pad pitches drop below thirty microns, mass transport bottlenecks restrict reactant diffusion into blind vias. Mechanical sparging generates convection currents that rarely reach the bottom of high-aspect-ratio cavities, starving via bases of nickel and palladium ions.

This fluid stagnation skews deposit thicknesses across the panel, leaving vias thin while surface pads plate heavy.

Ultrasonic agitation paired with wetting surfactants lowers surface tension enough to drive chemical exchange down into sub-thirty micron vias. Bath additives like thiourea derivatives and sulfur suppressors help rein in deposition rates at high-current-density pad edges, preventing nodular buildup. Uniform plating across the entire panel array avoids height variations between microbumps, which otherwise produce open joints during flip-chip die attach.

Thinning the palladium layer below zero point zero three microns accelerates line throughput, but compromises solder joint integrity under extended thermal stress.

Bond

Solder-pad interfacial reactions dictate how well a package survives mechanical and thermal stress. During liquid-phase reflow, lead-free solder alloys ~ chiefly tin-silver-copper ~ react with the pad plating to form intermetallic compound layers. The thickness, crystal morphology, and growth rate of these intermetallics govern joint toughness under drop shock and thermal cycling.

Various material swatches including textiles slate and metal finishes are arranged on a dark display board inside a sample evaluation room.

Intermetallic Compound Layer Evolution

The solder joint interface shifts rapidly during reflow as copper, nickel, and tin diffuse across the contact zone. On ENEPIG, molten tin dissolves the outer gold cap within seconds, then strips the underlying palladium to reach the electroless nickel. Tin and nickel then react, forming a ternary nickel-copper-tin intermetallic compound.

The nickel deposit functions as the primary diffusion barrier throughout this reaction.

Soldering with high-copper alloys like SAC305 draws copper from the solder bulk toward the pad, forming a hexagonal intermetallic phase. Continued copper migration converts this into a complex ternary layer, altering interface stresses and grain structure. Prolonged thermal aging past one hundred twenty degrees Celsius accelerates solid-state diffusion, thickening the intermetallic layer while pulling nickel out of the underlying phosphorus-rich deposit.

A bespoke metal and composite receptacle with illuminated trim features in a modern industrial setting.

Microbump Solder Joint Phase Transformations

Lead-free solder balls reacting with substrate metallization develop crystal structures that depend directly on the plating bath’s phosphorus concentration. As tin consumes nickel from the electroless deposit, the remaining, unreacted nickel layer becomes enriched in phosphorus. This band forms a metastable nickel-phosphorus phase right against the intermetallic boundary.

Phosphorus steadily accumulates along the reaction boundary as nickel is consumed.

A fifty-micron flip-chip microbump reflowed onto an ENEPIG pad illustrates the transition. Initial reflow at two hundred forty-five degrees Celsius for forty-five seconds yields a one point two micron intermetallic layer. After five hundred hours of thermal storage at one hundred fifty degrees Celsius, solid-state diffusion drives that layer to two point eight microns, while the neighboring phosphorus-rich band expands from two hundred nanometers to six hundred nanometers.

This concentrated phosphorus layer introduces localized mechanical stress, leaving the bump prone to brittle fracture under impact.

Gold concentrations exceeding one point five weight percent in lead-free solder interconnects induce needle-like gold-tin intermetallic precipitation that causes low-stress brittle failure under mechanical shock.
A digital render reveals a modular structural corner frame assembly containing wood components and metal profiles alongside a steel spring inside corrugated cardboard packaging.

Gold and Aluminum Wire Interface Stability

Thermosonic wire bonding requires surface finishes that stay oxide-free while facilitating atomic diffusion. Gold wire bonding on ENEPIG depends on solid-state intermetallic growth between the wire tip and the immersion gold layer. The intermediate palladium prevents nickel from diffusing to the surface during pre-heating, keeping the bonding surface clean.

Aluminum wire bonding creates aluminum-gold and aluminum-palladium intermetallics, relying on ultrasonic energy to fracture surface oxides and establish direct metallic contact. Copper wire bonding ~ used to cut costs and boost electrical conductivity ~ demands strict limits on plating hardness and topography. Overly hard nickel or rough palladium can cause pad cratering during wedge bonding, where ultrasonic energy cracks the dielectric laminate directly beneath the copper pad.

Thicker gold deposits improve wire bond pull strength, but they compromise the toughness of lead-free solder joints under shock loads.

Fracture

Interfacial fractures in microelectronic assemblies trace back to chemical and physical flaws created during substrate finishing. These plating defects pass standard visual inspection undetected, only to trigger package failures during downstream thermal assembly or in the field. Pinpointing root-cause failure mechanisms lets packaging engineers adjust bath chemistry and maintenance cycles before suspect substrate lots leave the fab.

Material samples and a miniature crane model rest on a metallic workbench inside a manufacturing facility sample room.

Does ENEPIG Eliminate Black Pad in Fine Pitch Packages?

The electroless palladium layer in ENEPIG acts as a barrier during immersion gold plating, curbing galvanic corrosion. In standard ENIG, gold deposits by displacing nickel: gold ions take electrons from the electroless nickel, releasing nickel into solution. If the gold bath is too aggressive or the nickel deposit has localized phosphorus variations, chemical dissolution eats deep into nickel grain boundaries.

This galvanic attack corrodes deep crevices directly along the grain boundaries.

The resulting fissures fill with dark nickel oxide and elemental phosphorus ~ the defect known as black pad. ENEPIG prevents this corrosion because the autocatalytic palladium layer separates the nickel deposit from the gold bath. Gold ions exchange electrons with palladium instead of nickel, preserving the structural nickel layer underneath.

A heavy steel pipe with a welded flange rests diagonally across stacked corrugated cardboard blanks inside a metal storage warehouse.

Hyper Corrosion Dynamics in Electroless Nickel Deposits

Galvanic displacement during gold immersion can selectively attack grain boundaries in nickel-phosphorus deposits. When plating parameters drift, hyper-corrosion appears as microscopic spikes extending deep into the nickel. High bath temperatures, depressed nickel ion concentrations, prolonged immersion dwell times, and unstable pH all accelerate this attack.

  • Hyper-corrosion spikes open deep narrow voids along nickel grain boundaries that severely weaken physical interconnect strength.
  • Phosphorus enrichment band forms an extremely brittle layer adjacent to the intermetallic joint interface following thermal reflow.
  • Gold embrittlement voiding occurs when dissolved gold precipitates along intermetallic boundaries as continuous, brittle phase arrays.
  • Substrate pad cratering manifests as micro-fractures extending into underlying laminate glass fibers caused by excessive wire bonding impact force.
  • Interfacial Kirkendall voids coalesce along copper-tin or nickel-tin phase boundaries under long-term high-temperature operating conditions.
A partially opened circular metallic container reveals a dark, compressed organic product, resting on a wire mesh background.

Kirkendall Voiding and Interfacial Brittle Failure

Sub-micron cavities collect along the interface between intermetallic growth fronts and the underlying nickel. These Kirkendall voids form due to unequal vacancy fluxes during solid-state diffusion: copper and nickel atoms migrate into the tin solder faster than tin moves back toward the substrate. This imbalance leaves behind uncompensated lattice vacancies that coalesce into micro-voids during thermal aging.

Tight control over layer thickness prevents these brittle interfacial failures.

Alternate finishes like immersion silver and immersion tin carry their own degradation modes. Immersion silver reacts with atmospheric sulfur to grow silver sulfide whiskers that bridge fine-pitch traces and cause shorts. Immersion tin builds up internal compressive stresses over time, sprouting conductive tin whiskers across sub-twenty micron pad spacings.

Releasing substrate lots plated with inadequate bath agitation introduces latent cracks that only appear during final assembly temperature cycling.

Bench

Quality verification depends on physical, chemical, and microstructural inspection protocols run at regular sampling intervals. Verifying compliance against international plating standards protects packaging lines from batch-level field failures. Inspection routines pair non-destructive metrology with destructive cross-sectional analysis to verify layer integrity.

A single liquid droplet rests inside a small white ceramic dish positioned next to a rotary polishing tool on a dark textured workbench.

Non-Destructive X-Ray Fluorescence Thickness Verification

X-ray fluorescence (XRF) instruments direct primary radiation at the substrate to excite secondary emissions within the metal stack, measuring discrete energy peaks to calculate individual layer thicknesses in ENEPIG deposits. Standard single-collimator XRF systems cannot resolve thin gold and palladium layers on fine-pitch pads because their beam spot spills onto adjacent solder mask.

Energy-dispersive XRF tools with polycapillary optics narrow the X-ray beam below twenty microns. This spot size allows precise thickness measurements directly on microbump pads without background interference from surrounding laminate. Technicians calibrate these instruments daily using certified multi-layer thin-film standards.

Daily calibration ensures measurement accuracy across varying production shifts.

Plating thickness specifications leave little margin. IPC-4552B governs electroless nickel immersion gold, while IPC-4556 defines limits for ENEPIG. Per IPC-4556, the minimum palladium thickness sits at zero point zero five microns, a baseline established during 2017 thermal aging evaluations on zero point four millimeter pitch ball grid array pads.

Sourcing experimental palladium deposits thinner than thirty nanometers introduces unquantified risks of Kirkendall void formation in microbumps exposed to thermal shock. To mitigate this, packaging buyers require five-hundred-cycle thermal shock qualification on prototype builds before approving reduced bath thicknesses.

A digital render shows an industrial logistics shed near railway tracks, containing stacked packaging boxes, glassware samples, and modular storage containers.

IPC Standard Testing Routines and Metallographic Cross-Sectioning

Destructive cross-sectioning uncovers internal microstructural defects within the plating stack. Test coupons are potted in cold-curing epoxy, ground with silicon carbide papers, and polished with diamond suspensions down to zero point one micron grit. An ammonium hydroxide etch then highlights intermetallic structures and hyper-corrosion crevices under a scanning electron microscope.

  1. Calibrate the X-ray fluorescence detector against certified multi-layer thin-film standards for palladium and gold thickness verification.
  2. Sample ten substrate pads per panel across four quadrant corners and the center region to establish coating uniformity.
  3. Mount selected coupon cutouts in cold-curing epoxy resin for cross-sectional grinding and mechanical polishing down to one-quarter micron diamond slurry.
  4. Perform scanning electron microscopy imaging at five thousand times magnification to inspect the nickel-phosphorus interface for hyper-corrosion crevices.
  5. Conduct high-speed ball shear testing at one meter per second velocity to quantify brittle interfacial fracture modes.
Surface Finish Inspection Standards, Methodologies, and Acceptance Limits
Property Target Standard Reference Test Methodology Acceptance Criteria
ENEPIG Layer Thickness IPC-4556 Polycapillary XRF Ni: 3.0 ~ 6.0 µm, Pd: 0.05 ~ 0.15 µm, Au: 0.02 ~ 0.05 µm
Hyper-Corrosion Depth IPC-4552B SEM / Cross-Section Crevices < 10% of Ni depth, Level 0 ~ 1 only
Solder Ball Shear Strength JESD22-B117 / IPC-TM-650 High-Speed Ball Shear Ductile failure mode > 95%, Shear force > 1.5 N/bump
Wire Bond Pull Force MIL-STD-883 Method 2011 Hook Pull Tester Au wire pull force > 0.03 N (25 µm wire diameter)
Plating Adhesion IPC-TM-650 2.4.1 Tape Pull Test Zero metal flaking or dielectric separation
An industrial worker inspects a wooden export crate with moisture testing droplets inside a dimly lit warehouse distribution center.

Solder Ball Shear and Wire Pull Diagnostic Protocols

Mechanical testing establishes joint strength prior to final module encapsulation. Solder ball shear testing drives a hardened chisel against reflowed bumps at specified standoffs and speeds. Low-speed testing at zero point one millimeter per second assesses bulk ductile deformation, whereas high-speed shear at one to two meters per second forces brittle interfacial fractures that highlight plating flaws.

Section 3.4.1 of the IPC-4552B surface finish specification states that nickel deposits containing Level 3 hyper-corrosion crevices over more than fifteen percent of the pad length demand immediate batch rejection.

Wire pull testing tensions wire loops with a calibrated micro-hook. The failure site reveals the weak link: breaks at mid-span indicate sound plating and bonding, while clean pad lift points to surface contamination, bath impurities, or incomplete intermetallic growth.

Rejection under Section 3.4.1 of IPC-4552B is mandatory whenever Level 3 hyper-corrosion extends across more than fifteen percent of the pad interface.

Scrap

Excess precious metal consumption and depleted bath chemistry drive substantial yield and material losses in substrate manufacturing. Plating gold or palladium beyond upper specification limits consumes expensive metal without performance benefit. Conversely, thin deposits fail receiving inspections, scrapping panels and driving up total landed package costs.

Industrial metal components and assorted surface finish swatches rest on a clean workbench inside a manufacturing facility with large windows.

Gold Over-Deposition Financial Exposure

Operating variation in immersion and autocatalytic plating cells frequently pushes deposits above target thicknesses. Between bath drag-out and over-plating, high-volume substrate operations face ballooning raw material expenses unless plating distributions remain tightly centered.

Compounding yield fallout at this stage directly elevates total landed package costs.

Consider a substrate facility running fifty thousand panels per month. Panels measure five hundred ten millimeters by five hundred fifteen millimeters, with thirty-five percent copper coverage. Target gold thickness is zero point zero three microns, but process drift pushes the actual average to zero point zero five five microns.

Gold density sits at nineteen point three grams per cubic centimeter, and the spot price is sixty-five US dollars per gram.

That represents an excess thickness of zero point zero two five microns across zero point zero nine two eight square meters of plated area per panel. Each panel takes on an extra two point three two cubic centimeters of gold, or four point four seven grams. Over fifty thousand panels a month, over-plating consumes two hundred twenty-three point five kilograms of surplus gold ~ an unbudgeted expense exceeding fourteen point five million US dollars.

Financial Sensitivity Matrix for Plating Thickness Drift and Drag-Out Losses
Monthly Panel Volume Gold Target Thickness Actual Plated Thickness Excess Gold Deposited Monthly Material Variance
10,000 Panels 0.030 µm 0.040 µm 0.893 kg $58,045 USD
10,000 Panels 0.030 µm 0.055 µm 2.232 kg $145,080 USD
50,000 Panels 0.030 µm 0.040 µm 4.465 kg $290,225 USD
50,000 Panels 0.030 µm 0.055 µm 11.162 kg $725,530 USD
Calculations assume 35% substrate surface copper coverage on 510mm x 515mm panels and $65/g gold commodity price.
Worker handling custom molded foam protective packaging near a freight transport trailer at a warehouse loading bay.

Chemical Drag-Out and Replenishment Unit Economics

Panels exiting plating tanks pull chemistry with them. This drag-out strips palladium and gold ions from active cells into rinse stages, forcing chemical additions to hold tank concentrations steady. Increasing withdrawal speeds from eight milliliters per panel to fourteen milliliters per panel sharply accelerates chemical consumption.

Drag-out carries expensive dissolved metals out of the active bath and into wastewater streams.

Reclaiming precious metals from rinse tanks demands dedicated ion-exchange systems, which add operating and maintenance costs to panel fabrication. Air-knife wipers positioned over process tanks blow fluid back before panels clear the bath, cutting drag-out losses by forty percent.

Six sequential panels within a technical render demonstrate a mechanical tool apparatus systematically clearing a white bead from a dark metallic plate.

Substrate Yield Calculations across Fine Pitch Arrays

Panel defect distribution dictates final usable die cost in advanced packaging. Plating defects ~ nickel skip, palladium nodules, or surface oxidation ~ cause open circuits during assembly. On dense substrates carrying dozens of die sites per panel, a single un-plateable pad ruins the entire multi-layer site.

  • Chemical bath replenishment records verify real-time concentration tracking for palladium salts and reducing agents.
  • Coating thickness distribution logs track XRF measurements across panel quadrants to confirm plating cell uniformity.
  • Cross-section shear test dossiers document intermetallic failure modes under high-velocity mechanical testing.
  • Precious metal weight reconciliation statements balance input gold salts against total plated panel metal volume.

Allowing bath parameters to drift unchecked steadily erodes net panel yield.

Maintaining automated chemical replenishment systems reduces precious metal thickness standard deviation across high-density substrate panels by over thirty percent.

Whether autocatalytic gold chemistries can deliver sub-twenty nanometer thickness uniformity without accelerating bath decomposition remains an open question on high-volume sub-micron packaging lines.

Contract

Sourcing agreements turn physical plating tolerances into enforceable commercial remedies. Buying substrates from offshore manufacturing hubs introduces supply chain risks that clear contracts must account for. Technical plating specifications belong directly inside binding quality agreements with clear rejection thresholds.

Architectural material samples featuring textured panels and fabric swatches are displayed beside a minimalist ceramic vessel in a production studio.

Plating Specification Schedules in Sourcing Agreements

Purchase contracts should cite industry standards while defining explicit layer thickness windows. Technical appendices must state minimum and maximum thickness limits for every deposit. Loose references to standard commercial practice let suppliers ship marginal lots that pass initial dock inspections but fail during reflow.

Auditing offshore facilities confirms whether floor technicians actually maintain bath chemistries to specification.

Contract schedules must require lot-specific certificates of analysis with every shipment. Substrates arriving without plating thickness distributions or bath maintenance logs should trigger immediate receiving holds at cargo docks, withholding payment until independent laboratory testing validates the shipment.

A procurement specialist examines architectural finishes and material samples on a display table inside a manufacturing supplier showroom containing modular panels.

In-Line Quality Audits for Offshore Packaging Substrate Mills

Reviewing plating logs directly on the factory floor verifies adherence to chemical maintenance limits. Substrate mills in overseas hubs often extend bath run times past supplier recommendations to keep lines moving, allowing organic breakdown products to accumulate and cause nodulation or porous deposits.

Inspection frequency scales directly with the overall size of the production lot.

Unannounced audits by qualified technical personnel provide ground-truth visibility into plating lines. Auditors check auto-dosing records, atomic absorption logs, and deionized rinse water resistivity. Direct floor inspection confirms that operators respect rack loading densities and sparging pressures, preventing localized stagnation across high-density panels.

A metal optical module prototype hovers above layered square platforms inside a room overlooking a lit city skyline at night.

Defect Allocation and Commercial Claims Frameworks

Clear liability terms assign financial responsibility when bath contamination triggers packaging failures. Standard purchase orders usually limit supplier liability to replacing bare circuit boards ~ a remedy that falls far short when bad surface finishes scrap fully assembled, multi-die packages downstream.

Comprehensive agreements establish scrap liability escalation clauses. If receiving checks or assembly screening reveals plating defects above agreed acceptance quality limits, supplier liability expands to cover lost silicon, assembly labor, and expedited freight. Defect attribution protocols based on IPC cross-sectioning provide objective data to resolve commercial disputes across international borders.

Nomenclature

Substrate Yield Loss

Meaning ~ Industrial production standards identify this metric as the total variance between raw material volume entering a manufacturing stage and the usable product quantity exiting that same process.

Intermetallic Compound

Meaning ~ Crystalline substance forms between different metal elements during the soldering process and provides the essential metallurgical bond between the component and the circuit board.

Bath Chemistry

Meaning ~ Electroplating solution compositions are maintained within precise chemical limits to ensure uniform metal deposition during surface finishing processes.

EPAG Finish

Meaning ~ Electroplating applied ground finish represents a specialized surface treatment protocol utilized by manufacturing entities to provide precise dimensional control and enhanced oxidation resistance for metallic components.

Wire Bond Pull

Meaning ~ Mechanical test procedures in semiconductor manufacturing measure the force required to rupture a microscopic wire connection between a silicon die and its package.

ENEPIG Finish

Meaning ~ Advanced surface plating for printed circuit boards provides a reliable interface between copper traces and electrical components through the sequential application of nickel, palladium and gold layers.

Thermal Aging

Meaning ~ Degenerative processes describe the structural and chemical changes that occur within a component when it is subjected to elevated temperatures over an extended duration.

Electroless Nickel Immersion Gold

Meaning ~ Chemical plating process used in printed circuit board fabrication to deposit a layer of nickel followed by a thin layer of gold for solderability and environmental protection.

High Speed Shear Test

Meaning ~ Mechanical testing protocols for solder ball attachments measure the energy absorption and failure modes of metallic joints under rapid strain rates to predict drop impact performance.

Defect Allocation Schedule

Meaning ~ An administrative document defines the liability boundaries and financial responsibilities for production failures between a manufacturer and a contract holder.

XRF Metrology

Meaning ~ Non-destructive analytical methods in industrial manufacturing measure the thickness and elemental composition of metal coatings on a substrate.

Ball Shear Testing

Meaning ~ Mechanical measurement characterizes ball shear testing as a method for determining the interfacial strength between a solder ball and its substrate or pad.

What the firm knows, published

Expertise is a utility, not a secret. sentiention™ publishes its working knowledge as open reference: intelligence layer covering the materials it sources, the markets it enters, and the reference that serves both.