Meaning
Judicial rules that empower civil courts to demand financial records from defendants in intellectual property lawsuits. Under SPC IP evidence interpretation article 24, tribunals can shift the burden of producing financial documentation to the accused infringer once the plaintiff has made a reasonable effort to provide preliminary evidence. This rule addresses the problem of asymmetric access to business records in trade secret and patent disputes.
It provides a clear pathway for establishing damages.
Disclosure Mandate
Courts use this article to issue formal orders directing the defendant to submit their account books. In practice, the plaintiff must first show that the necessary documents are in the exclusive possession of the infringer. Once this condition is met, the tribunal orders the production of the records, leaving the defendant with no legal excuse to withhold them.
Evidentiary Presumption
If the defendant refuses to comply with the production order without a valid reason, the court can accept the plaintiff’s damage calculations. This provision, established under SPC IP evidence interpretation article 24, creates a strong incentive for defendants to cooperate with judicial audits. By refusing to disclose their books, defendants risk facing a judgment based on the plaintiff’s highest reasonable estimates.
This presumption directly counteracts the practice of hiding financial documents, ensuring that litigants cannot exploit their custody of records to escape liability.
Judicial Penalty
Non-compliance can also result in administrative fines or other procedural sanctions. The court may draw negative inferences regarding any facts that the withheld documents would have proven. This administrative pressure ensures that the trial proceeds efficiently and that the rights holder is not denied a remedy due to the defendant’s non-cooperation.