Meaning
Contract liability codifications establish the calculation principles and foreseeability boundaries for compensatory damages resulting from breach of contract. Prc Civil Code Article 584 defines the fundamental rule governing compensatory damages, stipulating that damages must equal the loss caused by the breach including expected contract profits. The statutory provision governs sales contracts, manufacturing agreements and cross-border commercial disputes adjudicated in Chinese courts.
It limits financial recovery by mandating that recoverable losses cannot exceed the damage that the breaching party foresaw or ought to have foreseen when concluding the contract.
Compensatory Scope
Financial recovery under this article covers direct losses alongside lost profits achievable under normal performance. Direct losses include damaged raw materials, wasted transport expenses and paid labor costs caused by a supplier delivery failure. Lost profits represent anticipated gross margins that the non-breaching party would have earned through resale or production had the contract been fulfilled properly.
Foreseeability Test
Damage claims are strictly evaluated against what the defaulting party understood at contract signing. Chinese judges analyze whether the defaulting factory received written notice of downstream buyer deadlines, retail penalty clauses or strict delivery windows before executing the purchase order. If a foreign buyer fails to disclose high liquidated damages clauses in downstream customer contracts, Chinese courts strike down claims for those consequential losses as unforeseeable under Prc Civil Code Article 584.
The foreseeability standard applies at the exact time of contract formation rather than at the time of breach, preventing parties from expanding liability by issuing late warnings after execution.
Judicial Application
Evidence requirements force claimants to prove direct causation and exact accounting of monetary losses. Claimants must present signed purchase orders, official tax invoices, accounting records and witness testimony to substantiate lost profit claims. Chinese courts reject speculative profit calculations, restricting damage awards to proven actual expenditures and documented historical profit margins.