Meaning
A statutory rule of election codified within the contract division of the civil legislation of the People’s Republic of China governs disputes where an agreement includes both an earnest money deposit and a liquidated damages clause. Under the terms of prc civil code article 588, when a contracting party breaches an obligation, the non breaching party must choose to apply either the deposit penalty or the liquidated damages clause, and cannot claim both remedies simultaneously. This statutory restriction applies to all commercial and civil agreements governed by the substantive law of mainland China, excluding transactions governed by separate foreign legal systems or offshore arbitration venues.
Remedy Selection
Litigation strategy requires an injured buyer to elect between reciprocal deposit forfeiture and contractual liquidated damages based on documented financial losses. If the statutory double deposit return yields a greater monetary recovery than the predetermined liquidated damages amount, the claimant requests the deposit mechanism. If actual enterprise losses exceed the deposit ceiling, the claimant elects liquidated damages instead.
The statutory text explicitly permits an injured party to demand general compensatory damages on top of deposit restitution if the deposit itself fails to cover total real losses.
Judicial Adjustment
Domestic courts maintain active supervisory authority over the final quantum awarded under whichever branch of remedy the plaintiff selects. If a plaintiff chooses liquidated damages under prc civil code article 588, the defendant may petition the court to reduce the award if it exceeds actual verified damages by more than thirty percent. Conversely, if the claimant demonstrates that liquidated damages are substantially lower than the actual operational damage sustained, the court may adjust the recovery ceiling upward.
Judicial oversight prevents punitive financial windfalls while guaranteeing equitable baseline restitution for documented commercial disruption.
Contractual Framing
Drafting supply agreements destined for domestic execution requires clear contractual structuring of both remedy mechanisms to preserve maximum flexibility during subsequent litigation. Contract drafters structure earnest money clauses and liquidated damage provisions in independent, severable paragraphs to prevent courts from striking down both remedies as mutually contradictory. Incorporating the exact statutory wording guarantees that should one mechanism fail due to procedural non compliance, the alternative route remains viable.
Clarity regarding actual damages records supports the claimant if an upward adjustment becomes necessary during judicial deliberation.