Meaning
Legal declarations made by a state during the ratification of the Multilateral Instrument allow it to exclude certain provisions from applying to its existing tax treaties. A part VI reservation prevents the mandatory binding arbitration rules from being integrated into the bilateral agreements of the reserving country. China utilized this opt-out to maintain sovereign control over the resolution of tax disputes with foreign governments.
This choice ensures that tax authorities are not forced to accept the decision of an independent panel of arbitrators.
Sovereign Control
State taxation officials prefer the traditional mutual agreement procedure which relies on consensus between two governments. By maintaining a part VI reservation, a nation avoids the risk of an unpredictable ruling that could override domestic tax policy. The absence of mandatory arbitration means that some disputes might remain unresolved if the two states cannot reach a voluntary settlement.
Treaty Interaction
Modifications to existing double taxation agreements occur only when both partner countries agree to the same sections of the Multilateral Instrument. If one country accepts arbitration but the other files a part VI reservation, the arbitration clause will not enter into force between them. The instrument acts as a matching engine that aligns the common positions of its signatories.
China’s choice affects a vast network of treaties, keeping the focus on the competent authority process.
Procedural Limit
Dispute resolution under the mutual agreement procedure remains an inter-governmental exercise without a guaranteed end date. The part VI reservation ensures that the timeline for resolving transfer pricing or permanent establishment issues is not dictated by an external schedule. Foreign investors should understand that their participation in the process is limited to providing information.
They cannot force the tax authorities to reach a conclusion within a specific timeframe. The final outcome depends on the bilateral relationship and the strength of the technical arguments presented by the enterprise.