Meaning
Civil litigation initiated without legitimate factual basis or justifiable legal right, prosecuted purposefully to extract illicit advantages or damage an economic competitor, constitutes an actionable tort. Malicious litigation violates Article 13 of the Civil Procedure Law, which requires all parties to civil legal proceedings to adhere to the principle of good faith. Courts, administrative bureaus, and commercial enterprises encounter this practice when bad faith applicants exploit structural procedural rules, emergency preservation mechanisms, or bad faith patent filings to stall commercial transactions, compromise competitors during funding rounds, or freeze inventory in global supply chains.
Procedural Characteristics
Claimants who orchestrate this form of abuse typically construct claims around weak or fraudulently acquired rights, such as preemptively registered utility models or hoarded design patents lacking true inventiveness. In cases of malicious litigation, the claimant files multiple lawsuits across disparate provincial jurisdictions, couples the complaints with asset preservation demands, and deliberately delays court hearings through serial jurisdictional challenges. The strategic intention is not to reach a definitive final judgment on the legal merits, but to generate immediate commercial paralysis by freezing the respondent’s bank accounts, blocking cross-border customs declarations, and frightening retail distributors away from the competitor’s product lines.
Judicial Countermeasures
Chinese courts have developed strong procedural filters to identify and penalize abusive filings during litigation. When a People’s Court identifies malicious litigation, judges exercise statutory powers under Article 115 and Article 116 of the Civil Procedure Law to dismiss claims with prejudice, fine culpable plaintiffs up to one million yuan, and place dishonest legal representatives in judicial detention for up to fifteen days. Judges increasingly scrutinize patent litigation where the underlying claim faces an active invalidation proceeding before the National Intellectual Property Administration, frequently staying the civil action or revoking previously granted preliminary property preservation orders to prevent economic extortion.
Tort Liability
Victims subjected to predatory legal proceedings maintain independent rights of action to recover operational losses under general tort law principles and specific Supreme People’s Court judicial interpretations. An enterprise damaged by malicious litigation can sue the abusive claimant in a separate civil action to recover actual commercial losses, attorney fees, expert witness costs, and business reputation damages. In flagrant scenarios involving deliberate fraud, falsification of evidentiary documents, or collusion to misappropriate commercial assets through fake judgments, courts transfer the underlying case dossier directly to public security organs for criminal prosecution under Article 307(1) of the Criminal Law governing sham litigation crimes.