Meaning
Legal obligations for restitution arise when a party gains property without legal basis and possesses it with knowledge of the lack of justification. Under the provisions of civil code article 987, the bad faith beneficiary must return the original benefit and any yields derived from it. This article serves to protect the rights of the original owner against those who knowingly exploit an error or an unlawful transfer.
Restitution Obligation
Statutory requirements within the People’s Republic of China Civil Code dictate that the recipient is not entitled to keep any increase in value. If the person was aware that the benefit was not theirs to take, civil code article 987 requires them to reimburse the rightful owner for the full value of the property. The obligation is absolute once the lack of legal grounds is established.
Liability Scope
The scope of liability under civil code article 987 extends to the depreciation of the property and any lost profits that the rightful owner would have otherwise earned. This includes interest. If the property is destroyed or lost, the bad faith party must provide full monetary compensation regardless of whether they were at fault for the loss.
Evidentiary Threshold
Evidence of the recipient’s state of mind at the time of the transaction is necessary to trigger the heightened liability of the provision. The burden of proof lies with the claimant to demonstrate that the defendant was aware of the lack of legal grounds. Once bad faith is established, the protection usually afforded to an innocent beneficiary is withdrawn.