Meaning
The distribution of the responsibility to prove a disputed fact dictates which party in a legal proceeding must produce sufficient proof to substantiate their claims. In Chinese administrative disputes, evidentiary burden allocation requires the government agency to prove the legality of its action, while in patent invalidation proceedings each party must prove the facts they assert.
Allocation Rule
In civil and administrative patent litigation, the general rule requires the party asserting a claim to provide the supporting evidence. However, this burden shifts to the defendant in cases involving infringement of manufacturing processes for new products, where the defendant must prove that their process is different. The administrative agency must establish that it followed correct procedures and applied the law accurately when its decision is challenged.
Procedural Consequence
Failure to meet the assigned burden of proof results in an adverse ruling. For foreign companies, this means they must maintain comprehensive records of their research and development to defend against administrative challenges.
Judicial Discretion
Judges and administrative examiners may adjust the distribution of proof based on fairness and the availability of evidence to each side. When one party holds exclusive control over the relevant production records, the court can order that party to produce the documents rather than requiring the claimant to prove the negative.